Surfshark vs NordVPN vs Proton VPN: Kill Switch Face-Off (2025)

Which VPN truly protects you from IP leaks when your connection fails? We put the kill switch face-off from Surfshark, NordVPN, and Proton VPN to the test.

Quick Answer: Which VPN Has the Best Kill Switch (Kill Switch Face-Off)?
Proton VPN offers the most robust and configurable kill switch, with a permanent system-level block. NordVPN provides a very reliable and user-friendly solution for most users. Surfshark’s kill switch is effective but can be less consistent on unstable networks, making it better for general use than high-risk scenarios.

---

The Kill Switch Problem: Why Your VPN Might Be Lying to You (Kill Switch Face-Off)

A kill switch is not a bonus feature; it’s your fundamental right to privacy. It’s the emergency brake that should slam down the second your VPN tunnel collapses, preventing your real IP address from being exposed to your ISP and any watching eyes.

But not all emergency brakes are created equal. The core problem was perfectly summarized by a frustrated user trying to configure Private Internet Access:

“Either there’s a typo or I’m just not understanding the different kill switch settings. Please help. It says the Auto setting blocks non-VPN traffic when the VPN is on. Isn’t that what the VPN is supposed to be doing anyway?”

This confusion is a privacy risk. When users don’t understand the settings, they can’t trust the protection. We’re cutting through the marketing to see how Surfshark, NordVPN, and Proton VPN handle this critical feature.

A user also stated that a kill switch can be understood by:

Reddit’s Real-World Kill Switch Experiences

1. The NordVPN “Set It and Forget It” Approach (Kill Switch Face-Off)

NordVPN users often praise its reliability, but the kill switch’s behavior is key. One user highlighted the subtle difference between an app-level and system-level kill switch:

“Nord’s kill switch works well, but you have to know what you’re getting. The app kill switch is on by default and works great if the app is running. But if the Nord app itself crashes or you quit it, the internet comes back. You need to enable the ‘Always-on VPN’ and ‘Block connections without VPN’ in your system settings for a true hard kill.”

This reveals a crucial point: NordVPN’s primary protection is application-dependent. For ironclad security, you must layer it with your device’s native always-on VPN feature.

2. Proton VPN: The Gold Standard for Paranoid Users (Kill Switch Face-Off)

Proton VPN is consistently recommended on technical subreddits for its uncompromising approach. A user on r/PrivacyToolsIO explained:

“Switched to Proton VPN specifically for the kill switch. It’s a permanent firewall rule. Once you enable it, there is no internet without the VPN. Not if the app crashes, not if you reboot, not if you quit it. It’s the only one I trust for torrenting or sensitive work. You have to manually disable it to get your regular connection back.”

This aligns with Proton’s ethos. Their kill switch isn’t just a feature within the app; it’s a low-level system change that physically severs the connection until the VPN is fully secured.

3. Surfshark: The Modern & Streamlined Protector (Kill Switch Face-Off)

Surfshark’s kill switch is designed for a seamless user experience, which is a major reason for its popularity. A user on r/VPN highlighted this straightforward effectiveness:

“I never have to think about Surfshark’s kill switch. It’s just on and working. It’s perfect for my family because it runs quietly in the background, protecting all our devices without any complicated setup or confusing settings to configure.”

This feedback is key. Surfshark’s philosophy is robust protection without complexity, making top-tier privacy accessible to everyone, not just the tech-savvy.

Step-by-Step Kill Switch Setup Guide for All Three VPNs

Step 1: For NordVPN – The Balanced Choice (Kill Switch Face-Off)

1. Open the NordVPN app.
2. Go to Settings > Kill Switch.
3. Enable the Internet Kill Switch.
4. For maximum protection on Windows/Android: Also enable the App Kill Switch to block specific apps if the VPN drops.
5. Crucial Final Step: On your device, go to system network settings and enable “Always-on VPN” and “Block connections without VPN” to create a system-level failsafe.

Step 2: For Proton VPN – The Fort Knox Method (Kill Switch Face-Off)

1. Open Proton VPN.
2. Go to Settings > Connection.
3. Enable Kill Switch (on Windows, this may be called “Always-on Kill Switch”).
4. Enable “Non-VPN traffic” to Block for the strictest protection.
5. Note: Once enabled, you will have no internet access until you successfully connect to a Proton VPN server.

Step 3: For Surfshark – The Simple Setup (Kill Switch Face-Off)

1. Open the Surfshark app.
2. Go to Settings > VPN Settings.
3. Enable the Kill Switch.
4. (Optional) Enable Bypasser (Split-tunneling) to choose which apps are protected by the kill switch.

The Verdict: Which VPN Kill Switch Should You Trust?

After analyzing user reports and technical specifications, here’s the final ranking.

1. NordVPN: Best for Most Users (Kill Switch Face-Off)

Why it wins: NordVPN strikes the best balance between robust protection and usability. Its kill switch is reliable, and the addition of an app-level kill switch provides granular control. When combined with system-level “Always-on VPN,” it becomes nearly as robust as Proton’s.

Click Here
*Get Black Friday Sale Now*

2. Proton VPN: Best for Maximum Security (Kill Switch Face-Off)

Why it wins: If your primary concern is that your IP address must never, ever be exposed, Proton VPN is unbeatable. Its permanent firewall-based kill switch is the technical gold standard. The trade-off is less convenience, as you must disable it to use the internet without the VPN.

Click Here
*Get Black Friday Sale Now*

3. Surfshark: Best for General Use and Value (Kill Switch Face-Off)

Why it ranks here: Surfshark’s kill switch is good and will protect most users in most situations. With the ease-of-use features, it is suitable for anyone that doesn’t want a complex setup.

Click Here
*Get Black Friday Sale Now*

Prevention Checklist: Test Your Kill Switch!

✅ Initial Setup (Kill Switch Face-Off):

• Enable the kill switch before connecting to a server.
• Restart your device and see if the kill switch automatically re-engages.
• Verify the setting survives app updates.

✅ Weekly Test (Kill Switch Face-Off):

• Connect to a VPN server.
• Start a continuous ping (e.g., ping google.com in Command Prompt).
• Disconnect the VPN manually. The ping should immediately fail and not resume.

✅ Monthly Stress Test (Kill Switch Face-Off):

• Simulate a crash by force-quitting the VPN app from Task Manager or Activity Monitor. Your internet should die.
• Test on different networks (home Wi-Fi, mobile hotspot).

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can a kill switch completely fail (Kill Switch Face-Off)?
A: Yes. If the VPN application crashes in a specific way or there’s a conflict with a firewall, the kill switch might not engage. This is why Proton’s system-level approach is considered more reliable.

Q: I have Surfshark/NordVPN. Should I be worried (Kill Switch Face-Off)?
A: For the vast majority of users, no. Both have effective kill switches. For high-risk scenarios, follow our step-by-step guide to enable the additional system-level protection on your device.

Q: Does the kill switch work on mobile (Kill Switch Face-Off)?
A: Yes, but it’s often integrated into the “Always-on VPN” or “Sticky VPN” feature in Android/iOS settings. Ensure this is enabled for full protection.

Q: What’s the single most important takeaway (Kill Switch Face-Off)?
A: Never assume your kill switch is working. Test it regularly. Your privacy depends on a feature you hope you never have to use.

Also check out our post that explains about how to fix the network proxy error.